The Met Police has found nothing wrong with the handcuffing of two black teenage boys in Walthamstow, stopped because they were “running”.
A video of the boys being handcuffed and searched outside Nandos in the High Street was widely shared on social media earlier this month, including by local MP Stella Creasy.
Filmed in September last year, the video showed two handcuffed teenagers being searched for drugs by a male and female officer while members of the public filmed the interaction.
Responding to onlookers, the male officer said: “As soon as he saw us he ran away, we had spoken to him and the first thing he said was ‘f*** off’.
“It’s an offence to swear and he’s now detained under the Misuse of Drugs Act.”
Giving his version of events, the boy told members of the public he was running to his cousin to “sort something out” when the officer stopped him and began asking questions.
He added: “I don’t need to answer him, he pushes me onto the wall saying ‘you’re detained’ and all that.
“Obviously I shouldn’t have used those words but… he’s harassing me for no reason.”
A sergeant in Walthamstow’s High Street safer neighbourhood team personally reviewed the body worn footage and said he found “nothing” wrong with the interaction.
Speaking to a stop and search monitoring group at Waltham Forest Council on April 20, Sgt Asad Chaudhary said he thought the boys’ behaviour was “not normal”.
He added: “If you watch for body worn footage… those young males made off from the police and were swearing.
“That is not normal behaviour, officers were very polite throughout the interaction
“Obviously that’s up to officers to justify handcuffs, but professional standards found nothing at all… The officers gave them sufficient grounds for stop and search, they were handcuffed to prevent escape.”
Stop and search group member Naaman Telfer said he understood the police have a “very, very, very” tough job, but questioned whether the police had a “reasonable level of suspicion” in this case.
He added: “You created a hundred other problems, that’s the big situation… these are 13 or 14-year-olds, young men, they have gone past actually caring because this is a normal function of their normal lives.
“The reason they don’t complain is because they don’t have faith in the complaints procedure.”
Met police statistics for the 12 months up to March 2022 show black people in Waltham Forest remain more than three times more likely to be stopped and searched than white people.
This is despite only one in four stops for all races in the borough resulting in an arrest or criminal charge.
Of the 7,000 stops carried out in the borough, the people most likely to be stopped and searched were males between 15-19 years old.
Speaking about the incident, a Met Police spokesperson said: "No unlawful items were made and no complaint was filed over the officers’ conduct.
“Following comments online the stop was subject to a review by officers from the Met’s Professional Standards Unit – no misconduct was identified.
“Our learning and training of stop and search is shaped by our complaints process and feedback that Londoners provide us.
“We are redoubling our efforts to listen, engage and explain why we do what we do, to make improvements based off individuals’ ‘lived experience’ and to build trust.
“Anyone who is concerned about how a stop and search is conducted should report it to the MPS online, or raise it to us on social media where the circumstances will be reviewed and action will be taken. We take all complaints seriously.”
They added that handcuffing is used when officers believe there is a safety issue, but that officer training is changing to improve de-escalation of tensions to avoid their use.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here